Sarah Michelle Gellar And Alyson Hannigan Get Crafty

It has been 12 years since Buffy the Vampire Slayer went off the air, but Willow and Buffy still hang out. Alyson Hannigan and Sarah Michelle Gellar were giving out some love on social media Saturday as the moms got together for a party at Alyson’s house. Gellar showed off some creative products she got to take home after the get-together.

.@alydenisof and @AlexisDenisof Thanks for such an awesome party and my new #Giraffe You are the #CraftMaster pic.twitter.com/XHVD9AgUBj

— Sarah Michelle (@SarahMGellar) May 23, 2015

Saturday was the third birthday of Hannigan’s daughter Keeva Jane. Alyson and husband Alexis Denisof, also her Buffy the Vampire Slayer co-star, are parents to 6-year-old Satyana Marie as well. Sarah and husband Freddie Prinze, Jr., have two children, 5-year-old Charlotte Grace and 2-year-old Rocky James. Gellar gushed about Hannigan’s crafting skills on her caption of an Instagram photo of the on-screen best friends.

“So this girl (#AlysonHannigan) and her husband (#AlexisDenisof) know how to throw a party. I thought I was good with the crafts, till I went to this party#CraftMaster Thanks for having the #PrinzeFamily I’ve never seen a farm and pony rides in Santa Monica before #NowIveSeenItAll”

But to hear Alyson tell it, Sarah has some crafting skills of her own. In a tweet earlier this month, the How I Met Your Mother star revealed she and Gellar had an unlikely run-in at a big box store.

I had a lovely time with @SarahMGellar when I ran into her at Michaels today. Our mutual love of crafting would make Willow happy I think.

— alyson hannigan (@alydenisof) May 7, 2015

While Sarah and Alyson are busy with birthday parties and glue sticks, fans of Buffy the Vampire Slayer are obsessed with the idea of a reunion. On the 12th anniversary of the show’s finale last week, ET Online asked Gellar if she’d revisit her most famous character.

“I’m a little on the old side. I feel like my walker [or my] cane would be the stake.”

Gellar is 38; Hannigan is 41. But age is not the only thing keeping Sarah from heading back into the Buffy fold. She’s not sure the team could deliver something that would meet with fan approval.

“I think it’s hard. What we created was such magic and I think that it’s very difficult to recreate that and I think that inevitably as much as fans say they want it, I fear that the expectation level would be very, very difficult for something like that. I would worry.”

Nonetheless, Gellar paid tribute to Buffy with a montage of photographs on her Instagram page. She thanked fans for “continuing to tell her story.”

[Image: Sarah Michelle Gellar/Instagram]